Comments on: Ethics of Outsourcing Pregnancy to India – Michael Sandel

By: MrNh2009

MrNh2009 — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 22:23:05 +0000

Why do you remove my comment ?!
I thought that america is land of free speech
there was no any bad language i use
are you a fraid of truth.

By: jaanusgirl

jaanusgirl — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 21:39:34 +0000

Feminism isn’t about becoming a man. It’s about being EQUALITY. Women do not desire male sexual organs, nor do women become lesbians to pose as men. There is so much diversity in the world that if one can’t comprehend this fact, then by simplifying this matter to just sexual organs you’re insulting people’s intelligence.

Women in the western world are less fertile due to chemicals, pollution, eating habits, etc. Outsourcing pregnancies allows them to become mothers. It should be done ethically

By: Mrmoc7

Mrmoc7 — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 20:52:30 +0000

“Women in the western world are less fertile due to chemicals, pollution, eating habits”

Oh, but India is a land of noble savages without pollution, sanitation mismanagement, chemicals, or unhygienic eating habits, where the people are still *one* with nature. Is this a joke?

Secondly, your first paragraph is a straw-man argument. I never made an argument in favor of the things you’re providing counter-arguments for. Reread what I wrote.

By: Mrmoc7

Mrmoc7 — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 20:34:01 +0000

For your information, India is undergoing MASSIVE industrialization. Their atmosphere is MORE polluted than the ones in the states. Their water and sewage treatment systems are inferior to the ones you have in the states. Indian mothers are no more *fertile* than American mothers. The reason these women want to outsource their pregnancy is because it would interfere with their careers. Since men don’t get pregnant, women who are hell-bent on achieving *EQUALITY* see pregnancy as a drawback

By: swastikstar2000

swastikstar2000 — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 20:27:09 +0000

No it is not a joke. I am from Gujarat, India I know there are mainly three classes of the people like in rest of the world viz. upper(May be over nutrition ed), middle(Balance nutrition ed ) and lower class(mostly malnutrition ed). Mostly in Gujarat middle class women are not orthodox will sometime fill pride to give some one chance to be parents and same time will be eager to earn some money since she need it being middle class.

By: swastikstar2000

swastikstar2000 — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 20:05:23 +0000

1st of all my intention to tell reality to the people here. I agree that India is undergoing massive industrialization. Their atmosphere is more polluted than in the states BUT ONLY IN METRO CITY AND INDUSTRIAL CITY. Small town and villages are still natural or near to nature. Majority of Indian populations are still living in these small town and villages and enjoying eating three times a day home cooked foods(Not like preservative added frozen in states) and mostly vegetarian. contd…

By: swastikstar2000

swastikstar2000 — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 19:12:45 +0000

Contd…

Most people are under nutrition ed compare to the over nutrition ed US people still healthier than US people. I am in US since last 6 years and I am seeing people here in US are physically and mentally more seek than there in India (Specially in Gujarat).

By: adamlivs

adamlivs — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 18:27:00 +0000

It has nothing to do with western women or indian women per se…The reality is that white women and men are becoming less and less fertile…They need to indigenous, black, brown and yellow women to birth their children because of how fertile our sisters are…They focus on India because white people understand there is a large population of black people there who are struggling under the yoke of globalization and the upper caste desire to be like white people, and they see opportunity…

By: ClarksonsinUSA

ClarksonsinUSA — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 18:00:59 +0000

We used IVF to have our twins in our 40s,my wife was the birth mother…………..I the genetic father…. We found a 23 year old egg donor that had the traits we wanted to pass on to our children… Bringing life where there was none is a good thing,and who knows maybe be the Europeans can slow or even stop their population slide..

By: ClarksonsinUSA

ClarksonsinUSA — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 17:14:29 +0000

The only reason fertility is lower in the WEST is due to the wide spread use of contraception as well as putting off having children 2 later in life…

We have 7 sons …………..The last 2 through ivf,we gave 8 embryos to a Christian couple in the SOUTH…